Imitation is the sincerest form of flattery, as the saying goes, and in Blacklyte’s case, it’s flattering the heck out of Secretlab. The Blacklyte Atlas gaming desk—from the product’s webpage to the actual desk itself—appears to me as being very heavily influenced by the Secretlab Magnus Pro desk.

The Atlas isn’t a direct 1:1 copy but it’s pretty close, and for some people that actually might be a good thing. After all, getting a Secretlab desk for a not-Secretlab price would be awesome. Except that’s not the case here, as Blacklyte is asking $999/£899 for its gaming desk, more than the base version of the Magnus Pro. Even if you add optional extras to the latter, such as more cable management, a PC mount, and a headphones hanger, it’s still cheaper.

Now, if the Atlas was noticeably better than the Magnus Pro, that would be understandable. But it’s not. Don’t get me wrong: the Blacklyte Atlas is a pretty good gaming desk but the China-based company has missed the mark with how it’s set the price.

So what exactly are you getting for your thousand dollars bar a buck? It’s a motorised, height-adjustable fully steel desk, replete with RGB lights, a big cable management tray, and a full-desk mouse pad.

I have to say that my first impression was of great concern because the two boxes (one containing the desk surface and tray, the other for the legs) looked as if they’d made their way through four war zones, a hurricane, and an industrial car wash for good measure to reach my office. Fortunately, the contents were in good fettle, so I set about putting it all together.

The instruction manual suggests using two people and having lots of empty space to build the Atlas, but I decided to see if I could do it all by myself and in my rather small office.

I have to say that it was very easy to put together, nor did I require lots of room to do it, but the final step of flipping the finished build onto its legs was beyond my feeble frame. The Blacklyte Atlas is pretty heavy, a little under 30 kg (66 lbs) in weight and combined with its overall size, rotating about the x-axis is a two-person job.

Once upright, I was greeted with a bit of a disappointment. The top surface of the desk is entirely covered with a leatherette mouse pad that magnetically attaches to the steel top. The edge nearest where one would use the desk had large ripples in it and despite using lots of heavy objects to smooth it out, I wasn’t able to completely remove them.

That particular issue just could be with this review sample but if I had paid $999 of my own money on this desk, I’d be considerably less than happy.

What I was pleased with were the motorised legs. They’re incredibly solid and even at full height, the desk barely moves, although it’s best suited for use on a hard floor. My office has a carpet with a thick pile and it did cause some very minor wobbles with the legs fully extended. The action is adjusted via buttons on the right-hand side of the desk’s front panel, with an LCD display indicating the height.

There are only two memory presets available, fewer than the Secretlab Magnus Pro, but I suspect that would be more than enough for most users. There’s a handy button at the far right that locks the buttons from being accidentally pressed, but the desk is more than wide enough to ensure that this is unlikely to ever occur.

The Blacklyte Atlas is fitted with a collision detection system, which cuts power to the lifting motors if a blockage is detected. Unfortunately, it only kicks in if the desk is seriously impeded by something: I wouldn’t want to test out whether it’ll barge right past a trapped finger or not.

On the other side of the front panel, there are five buttons for enabling and controlling the RGB lighting: one each for the front strip, the side strips, and the corner lights. Blacklyte claims that the corner lights are magnetic with a “collision-resistant structure” and that they have “built-in RGB fantasy LED lights, support[ing] 1600W true color display.”

I can’t vouch for the actual power output of all the lighting but it’s certainly very bright. In fact, the front strip is so bright, that it’s very distracting when you’re sat at the desk, working or gaming. One can alter the lights through three modes (yellow, green, red, blue, or pulsing between them all) but you can’t change the brightness at all. Fortunately, switching the front strip off makes the desk far more pleasurable to use.

Blacklyte also claims that the lights can “sync with PC programs and match gaming algorithms to enhance gaming experience” via a length USB Type-A cable, but the PC I connected it to didn’t recognise them in any way. Confusingly, the manual actually says that the “host computer cable” is for “desktop height-adjustment control.”

Speaking of cables, the Atlas has a large section at the rear of the desk that can flip open, revealing a cavernous tray for hiding cables. It’s a bit too large and if you don’t like having monitors right in front of your face, then they need to rest on top of the tray’s lid. I can imagine that having to move screens about every time you want to get into the tray would become irksome rather quickly.

There’s a reasonably sized gap between the tray lid and the desk surface itself which should, in theory, permit the use of monitor arms. However, such devices would end up digging into the mouse pad and permanently marking or even cutting it.

One good thing about the Atlas is that the mains power cable that supplies electricity for the lights and lifting motors plugs into a socket at the bottom of the left leg. At the top of the same leg, there’s a general power outlet that you plug the desk’s power controller into. However, one can plug an extension strip into that socket instead and then power up the desk via the strip.

This allows you to place the strip in the cable tray, providing sockets to power monitors, accessories, and potentially even your gaming PC. Blacklyte states that the outlet and associated wiring have a current limit of 10 amps, so you can’t massively load it up, but it does mean that you can avoid having wires dangling down the back of the desk.

That also avoids the potential issue of having the desk hoisting any wires or electrical strips off the floor when it’s at its maximum height.

Taken as a whole, there’s a lot to like with the Blacklyte Atlas gaming desk. It’s incredibly solid and spacious, easy to build (heft weight aside), and the mouse pad surface is genuinely comfortable. Unfortunately, there’s a lot to not like about the Atlas, such as the build quality in places, the overly bright lights, and the questionable accuracy of the marketing claims.

But the worst part about it is the price—it’s very expensive for what it is and if one treats it as a Secretlab Magnus Pro clone, then the price is even more unpalatable. If you can find one on sale, with a healthy discount, then it’s worth considering but I’d prefer the Blacklyte to just give it a more sensible price permanently. Either that or make the Atlas worthy of its current price tag.